April 24, 2007

Ideology v. Reality

    The inevitable ideological attacks against the UAW has begun. Just in time for the news that Toyota overtook General Motors in worldwide sales for the first time in history, the drumbeat has picked up in the pages of the business press: auto workers have to just buck it up and take the hit to save Chryslyer. Or so says Dennis Berman in The Wall Street Journal (subscribers only):

Forget about making better cars. Or even about the rise of private equity. The best way to understand the sale of Chrysler Group is as blood sport between parent DaimlerChrylser and its North American unions.

Is DaimlerChrysler willing to get fully ruthless with its employees, in spite of its well-hewn image as loveable corporate citizen? The answer will make for some gripping theater in the months ahead. That is because this deal really is about persuading the company's unions to roll back their own health and pension benefits.

    Really, is that the deal? The truth is that that is not an economic statement but an ideological statement. And there is a difference. Ideology urges Berman to see the challenge through a particular prism where workers are the problem or, at least, their benefits are the problem dragging down the fortunes of Chrysler.

    But, economics might actually lead one to a different conclusion. On health care, the economics would be solved overnight if Chrysler and the rest of the business community would park their moronic, blind ideology and support single-payer health care--which would, almost overnight, remove billions of dollars of costs from their bottom lines.

    And as for pensions--many companies, like General Motors actually have large pension liabilities because of THEIR CEO PENSIONS, not rank-and-file workers' pensions, which are funded. One solution, then, is to first slash CEO pay and pensions first. That's economics...okay, with a bit of ideology mixed in.

Apr 24, 2007 9:44:20 AM | Labor

4 Comments

Got-A-LUPA

Sure would like to read some of the hidden posts on this one, but my computer is too slow to follow those links from any site without trouble. Guess I need to invest in a newer computer to fully realize all the "pie in the sky" value of the wonderful wide world web.

Posted by: Got-A-LUPA | February 17, 2011 at 10:14 PM

The comments to this entry are closed.

NEXT POST
UAW Owning Chrysler? I don't really find this story to be too credible. UAW Group, Tracinda Discuss Bids for Chrysler By GINA CHON and JOHN D. STOLL April 23, 2007 Representatives of billionaire investor Kirk Kerkorian's Tracinda Corp., which has proposed a $4.5...
PREVIOUS POST
The Coming Attack Against Auto Workers--And You The real story bubbling within the auto industry is not the news that Toyota vaulted over General Motors in worldwide auto sales. Rather, it's the growing ideological--not economic--drumbeat that is gathering targeting the livelihoods of tens of thousands of auto...

JT

The Typepad Team

Search

Recent Comments